‘Unreasonable’ behaviour by Maldon District councillors could spark investigation

By Charlie Ridler - Local Democracy Reporter

22nd Jun 2022 | Local News

Photo: Ben Shahrabi
Photo: Ben Shahrabi

Claims of "unreasonable behaviour" and "pre-determination" of a planning application by Maldon District Council could spark an investigation.

The planning inspectorate said the Council "manufactured unsubstantiated reasons for refusal" when it refused permission for a cul-de-sac road and a bungalow in Stoney Hills, Burnham-On-Crouch last year.

At a meeting last Thursday (June 16) the council's joint standards committee voted to recommend the authority accepts the inspector's findings and conduct an internal investigation into how the matter was handled.

According to a council report, the application by Virium Technology Limited was refused in February 2021 but referred upwards to the district planning committee in June that year after the possibility of a legal challenge on the grounds of alleged pre-determination.

Here it was refused for a second time on the grounds the design was "incongruous and contrived" and would harm one of the site's neighbour's by reducing the outlook from their house.

The planning inspectorate later granted permission for the development on appeal and awarded costs against the council.

Monitoring Officer Simon Quelch said while the applicant had made allegations of pre-determination against the council in its application for costs, the inspector had only made its decision based on the unreasonable behaviour.

He also said it was very rare for inspectors to award costs against local authorities in appeals such as this, only doing so if there has been unreasonable conduct or "procedural defects" which put an appellant to unnecessary expense.

Councillor Adrian Fluker (non-aligned, Southminster) called for an external investigation on the grounds of impartiality, claiming planning appeals had already cost local council taxpayers over £250,000 so far this year.

He said: "Members now have the chance to demonstrate that they are prepared to scrutinise themselves."

But several members disagreed, and the committee eventually voted instead to recommend the matter be dealt with internally.

Councillor Emma Stephens (Independent Group, Tollesbury) said: "I'd really like to understand what we would like to get out of an external investigation which is going to add to the costs that the local residents would have to foot, that we wouldn't be able to achieve ourselves."

The full council will now debate whether to approve the recommendation to launch an investigation later this year.


Related Articles

The Farleigh team with the heart of Forget-me-Not messages: Diane Meah, Hannah Tomsett, Lois Matthams, Pauline Harvey-Jones, Sabrina Rees-Evans, Michelle Martin and Claire Smith
Local News

Farleigh Hospice to hold annual remembrance service this Saturday

Plume Academy is looking for a cleaner. (Photo: Plume Academy)
Local News

Help create a positive learning environment for children, with these 3 school jobs near you

Nub News Logo

Sign-up to the Maldon Nub News weekly newsletter

Subscribe now for weekly updates of local news and sport from your town. Plus what's on near where you live - and local homes for sale. All delivered straight to your in-box, every Friday.

We won't pass your details on to anyone else. By clicking the sign-up button you agree to our Privacy Policy.